Home Our Hope
Bible Study OurHope Emblem June 16, 2012
Divination
A photo of a glowing crystal ball behind some Tarot cards with hands waving around the crystal ball.

Introduction

A dictionary says that Divination is seeking knowledge by supernatural means1. We'll see that the Bible's definition is a little different. Usually the knowledge that people seek is about the future so that they can make good decisions. The Bible tells us that divination is wrong, and some of the kinds of divination it proscribes are still present in society. But our society has developed new and sometimes more subtle methods of divination. This study looks at all of this.

Also the Bible allows some kinds of divination, such as casting lots, which we see the apostles using after Judas' death to pick a replacement apostle2. Also, the Old Testament priests used two stones called the Urim and Thummim to divine God's will. This lesson will also look at why these are acceptable to God, when other methods are not.

Study

In Deuteronomy, Moses is giving the last instructions to the Israelites before they go into the promised land. He reminds them of the things that have happened during their 40 years in the desert and of the things that God has told them. In chapter 29 he says to the Israelites:

29The secret things belong to the Lord our God, but the things revealed belong to us and to our children forever, that we may follow all the words of this law. (Deuteronomy 29:29)

This tells us much. There are many things that God knows that no one else knows. If he chooses, he can reveal such hidden things as he chooses to reveal. Remember what Daniel said about God in Daniel 2 after God had revealed to him Nebuchadnezzar's dream and its meaning.

22He reveals deep and hidden things […] (Daniel 2:22)

But the other side of the verse from Deuteronomy is that some hidden things are not revealed, and that leaves room for people to pretend they can reveal them. Divination is an attempt to reveal these hidden things.

The longest list of methods of divination that God proscribes comes from Deuteronomy 18, where Moses is giving the Israelites instructions before entering the promised land.

9 When you enter the land the Lord your God is giving you, do not learn to imitate the detestable ways of the nations there. 10 Let no one be found among you who sacrifices their son or daughter in the fire, who practices divination or sorcery, interprets omens, engages in witchcraft, 11 or casts spells, or who is a medium or spiritist or who consults the dead. 12 Anyone who does these things is detestable to the Lord; because of these same detestable practices the Lord your God will drive out those nations before you. 13 You must be blameless before the Lord your God. (Deuteronomy 18:9-13)

As you can see, this lists some practices that are still in use today. There is a problem in the translation though. No one fully understands the Hebrew words that describe these practices. Some of the words are lost in time, and some describe practices that we do not have today, so there is no word to translate to. Therefore if you compare different translations of these verses, you will see differences in the lists, or perhaps completely different lists.

Deuteronomy 18:10-11
NIVLSBLSV
sacrifices their son or daughter in the firemakes his son or his daughter pass through the fireone causing his son and his daughter to pass over into fire
divinationdivinationa user of divinations
sorcerysoothsayingan observer of clouds
interprets omensinterprets omensan enchanter
engages in witchcraftis a sorcerera sorcerer,
casts spellsis an enchanterand a charmer
is a medium or spiritistis a medium or spiritistone inquiring from a familiar spirit, a wizard
one who consults the deadone who inquires of the deadone seeking to the dead

That means we really don't know what most of the practices are. If that is true, how can we know what things God doesn't want us to do?

If we look at the Hebrew, it has "divination" as a noun and follows that with a bunch of verbs. There are other places in the Bible where a long list appears. In those it is clear that the reader is to find the underlying principle. In this case, the intent is the same. The verbs are examples of practices that are divination. Therefore understanding the specific practices is less important than understanding divination. The practices change over time.

We should never use this list as a checklist and say, "it's not on the list, so it's OK."

As mentioned above, we see some practices in the Bible that look like they could be divination, but they are acceptable. What makes casting lots acceptable but not Tarot cards? What is the underlying principle that we can apply to everything in our lives? The answer is somewhat hidden in the verses that continue from the ones above.

The nations you will dispossess listen to those who practice sorcery or divination. But as for you, the Lord your God has not permitted you to do so. 15 The Lord your God will raise up for you a prophet like me from among you, from your fellow Israelites. You must listen to him. (Deuteronomy 18:14-15)

A note on the context of the verses above from Deuteronomy is important here. Verse 14 says not to listen to these diviners. The following verse talks about a coming prophet. The message is that the people should listen to him. That prophet would be the Messiah. However the people of Israel listened to the ones they shouldn't and killed the one they refused to listen to.

Also note that verse 14 says nations will be dispossessed (kicked out of their land) for listening to these diviners. Israel listened to their "diviners" instead of their Messiah, and God kicked them out of Israel for nearly 2000 years. So verse 15 is a warning and a prophecy for Israel. This should be a warning to us as well.

Now look at this verse from 1 Samuel 15, where Samuel is telling Saul what he has done wrong.

23 For rebellion is like the sin of divination, … (1 Samuel 15:23)

Saul was given explicit instructions by God through Samuel, but he didn't follow them exactly. Instead he did some things that he probably thought would be even more pleasing to God. He was rebelling by not following God's instructions. But how is this like divination? Saul didn't use any divination techniques like reading bones or consulting spirits. The answer, which leads us to the underlying principle, is that Saul had consulted himself to determine what actions he should take.

So the answer is that it is less about the methods than about who you are consulting. What makes any method acceptable is that you are seeking hidden knowledge from God. Therefore what makes any method wrong is seeking hidden knowledge from anyone or anything else, whether it be from the dead or from a living interpreter of something. God should be the one that we go to for answers; anything else is a false god.

In Isaiah 8, Isaiah makes this point that it matters who you consult.

19 When they say to you, "Consult the mediums and the spiritists who whisper and mutter," should not a people consult their God? Should they consult the dead on behalf of the living? (Isaiah 8:19)

Hosea says something similar.

My people consult a wooden idol, and a diviner's rod speaks to them. A spirit of prostitution leads them astray; they are unfaithful to their God. (Hosea 4:12)

Don't think that I am saying the methods used for divination don't matter. The methods that God has listed should never be used, even if you believe you are seeking knowledge from God through them. Therefore you should never go to a medium to ask for God's guidance. You should go to God with your question.

That doesn't mean God will give you an answer or that he will give that answer in the time that you want it. God withholds those things he wishes to withhold. We should take that as an excuse to consult some other source and try to do an end-run around God.

Now that we have the underlying principle, we can understand why it was acceptable for the apostles to cast lots to determine Judas' replacement. In fact, the verses from Acts 1 spell that out clearly.

23 So they nominated two men: Joseph called Barsabbas (also known as Justus) and Matthias. 24 Then they prayed, "Lord, you know everyone's heart. Show us which of these two you have chosen 25 to take over this apostolic ministry, which Judas left to go where he belongs." 26 Then they cast lots, and the lot fell to Matthias; so he was added to the eleven apostles. (Acts 1:23-26)

This is the last time in the Bible's timeline that we will see them asking God for a decision based on a method. Shortly after this, they will receive the Holy Spirit. I'm told that the term "casting lots" appears 7 times in the New Testament, though I could only find 6. All of them appear before the Holy Spirit is given. From then on, they will have the guidance within them that they need.

We also, for the same reason, should not be using methods to determine the will of God. I have to admit, though, that there have been times when I was too conflicted about the choices I had to make.

This principle also explains why the priests' Urim and Thummim stones were acceptable. They are mentioned so rarely that we don't know much about them or how they were used. But doubtlessly they were consecrated to God, and as we saw with the apostles above, the priest would have prayed for God to show his will before using the stones.

So now that we have the underlying principle, let's apply it to some techniques for divination in our society.

PracticeWho Is Being Consulted
Praying and asking the Holy Spirit to show which choice to makeGod
HoroscopeJeane Dixon, et. al. / positions of stars, planets, earth, moon, birthday
Tarot CardsCard reader / cards / possibly a demon
Palm ReaderPalm reader / lines on your palm / possibly a demon
Medium, SpiritistMedium, spiritist / the dead / possibly a demon
Ouija BoardHuman body motions / possibly a demon
Drawing names from a hat / picking strawsRandomness
Reading Nostradamus' QuatrainsNostradamus / ?
Living Christian ProphetsProphet / ?
Listening to Authors about the Mayan Calendar's roll-over date in DecemberAuthors / Mayans / Mayan Calendar
Financial PlannerFinancial planner / financial trend predictions
Christian booksAuthors (Christian ?) / Bible
Asking for advice from friends, relatives, movie stars, political advisorsFriends / their understanding of the world

We can summarize these practices this way.

Note that the right decision may not be the decision that gives you the best result or the result you wanted. God's guidance may lead you into hard times, for the sake of your growth.

You may ask, if I turn every decision over to God, haven't I just become a mindless robot for God? When do I get to make decisions? But the truth is that with every decision you make, you choose between God's way and some other way. God's way will always be the best way because he is God Omniscient; we are only children. Perhaps as we mature we will know him so well that we will automatically make the decision he would want us to make. But living in these bodies and in this world, we are easily deceived.

Decisions About the Future

Ideally every Christian would know the Holy Spirit's leading and make the right decision. But we know this doesn't always happen, and our evidence often comes when we see a group of Christians who can't agree on a decision. On a personal level, we are sometimes too emotionally or politically involved, or some other factor has swayed us. In short, sometimes we are hearing what we want, not what God wants.

Rather than "casting lots" or something similar, God would much rather that we follow his leading. We can do this best by making sure that our relationship with God is solid and that there are no issues outstanding between us and God. We also need to clear out any conflicts we have, any things of the world that want to affect the decision. Then prayer is required, possibly prayer over many days. Then we need to make the decision and move forward in faith. God knows the decisions we face and will guide us if we will trust in him.

I'm sure many books have been written on this topic, and I can't do it justice here.

As mentioned above, there are times when a group of Christians cannot agree. Or sometimes the decision is so critical, or other factors are affecting them so strongly, that they just don't trust themselves to make the decision. In times like these, I think it is reasonable to pray that God will show his will by affecting the outcome of some "random" event, such as drawing a card from a deck, picking a name from a hat, or tossing a coin or die.

I think these methods are better than voting, which we in democratic countries often turn to. When you have a group of Christians who can't agree, you already know that you have a conflicted group and other factors are at play. So leaving the decision to a vote is really consulting a conflicted group of people, instead of God.

The Other Side of Divination

Divination isn't only trying to get information without consulting God. The other side is sorcery, where a person tries to exercise control without consulting God. Both are a rejection of God's authority, attempts to circumvent it. Therefore they fall under the 1st of the Ten Commandments, "I am the Lord your God."

There are lots of techniques for this, including magic spells, voodoo, and so on. As with trying to get information, the problem isn't so much the method as the heart that wants to do it.

The point is also not whether there are techniques for both that work. Again, it's the heart.

Conclusion

We would all like to know the future. That would give us some comfort, but it isn't the Christian life. Instead God wants us to walk in faith.



1 Encarta Dictionary - Microsoft Word

2 Acts 1:26